Weekend Movies: Brit critics, fanboys tilt “Mockingjay” reviews


Looking at the all-important Rottentomatoes Tomatometer on Monday, your eyes might have popped at the near 90% positive rating the latest “Hunger Games” film, “Mockingjay — Part 1,” was earning.

Those are “Gravity” numbers, “Avatar” level appreciation.

Then you scan the list and see it’s British critics who got to see the film earlier — at a junket, earlier opening. Overwhelming endorsements. Well, they are the elder culture. Defer to the Limeys, right?

About 30 minutes into the film Tuesday night, I rolled my eyes, cast my third look at my watch (wore a battery out checking the time) and thought, “The wankers. What do they know?”

Teenage girls were lining up last night, filling shows at a theater where I was seeing a preview of “A Most Violent Year,” reminding us that “Games” is still most generously described as a femme-centric “YA” sci-fi piece, appreciated for the empowering hints in its heroine, mockable for its insipid “Extreme Makeover: Future Fashionista” elements.

Endorsing this is pandering to an audience that will make it a hit. Endorsing it, in a fanboy sense, is confusing “dark” and “murky” and downbeat for “deep.”

American reviews — mine was the first — started knocking this dog down. It sits at an overly generous 70% on the tomatometer, a more realistic 63 on the more reliably accurate Metacritic meter.  American critics are very divided on it.

Not an awful film, just a space-filler between “Catching Fire” and the pointlessly split off “Mockingjay Part 2.” Passable director, straight from TV’s “Gotham” and “I Am Legend.” Dopey, action-starved script. They might have gotten a decent movie, with a real arc to the story, had they done the whole novel. Cynically, they cashed in by splitting it.

And Jennifer Lawrence is cell-phoning it in in between taking selfies. The worst acting this Oscar winner does is in the movies that made her rich.

It’ll make a billion, but that’s no endorsement. This same crowd subjected the universe to “Twilight” sequels and made “Divergent” a hit. Sci-fi lite, vampire romances, etc. It’s a cultural phenomenon in a faddish sense, not some lasting contribution to film or literature. Not to rain all over teenage girls and their latest mania.

About Roger Moore

Movie Critic, formerly with McClatchy-Tribune News Service, Orlando Sentinel, published in Spin Magazine, The World and now published here, Orlando Magazine, Autoweek Magazine
This entry was posted in previews, profiles and movie news, Reviews. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Weekend Movies: Brit critics, fanboys tilt “Mockingjay” reviews

  1. João says:

    Hunger Games isn’t just another mania. You should have provided more attention in history. Without doubt the last movie will be unforgettable. Have a lot of action for even happen.

    You are one of hate all that is part of young universe, just think “It’s a twilight”, very clichê and ridiculous, after all there is a romance in the trilogy, but isn’t the main point as other books you mentioned.

Comments are closed.