My least favorite “Toy Story” movie takes a solid hour to deliver its first laugh and some 70 minutes to truly get underway.
“Toy Story 5” tells a tale from three different points of view, with three storylines, and hammers its message about “tech” gadgets getting in the way of childhood “play,” development, socialization and creativity with a jackhammer.
But listening to the giggles of children in the viewing audience for the lame “wedding” finale, preceded by a toy “wedding” prologue, you remember “This isn’t for you — it’s for kids.” And if they’re laughing at toilet training humor — “You said DUTY, hehheheheh” and “He will WIPE your a…” it’s working. After a fashion.





But “Toy Story 5” has so much re-casting of voice actors — it’s been thirty years since the first film came out, and Jim Varney, Don Rickles and Estella Harris have passed away, Wallace Shawn clung to Woody Allen past his “canceled” date — that surely it must have occurred to the accountants at Disney/Pixar that they’ve been to this well a few too many times.
Having the toys face their own mortality — an incinerrator at a garbage dump (“Toy Story 3” — was always going to be impossible to top.
But this Andrew Stanton/McKenna Harris project does its best to wrestle with the ideas that kids are “growing up too fast” thanks to “tech” and social media, and that tactile toys force development of imagination in ways that passive “screens” do not, into a kids’ cartoon.
Their narrative follows three threads, at least one of which feels like a (weak) stand-alone “Toy Story” movie or spinoff all its own.
The surviving older toys now entrusted to little Bonnie’s (Scarlett Spears does the voice) care are led by rootin’, tootin’ ’50s cowgirl/sheriff Jessie (Joan Cusack), with spaceman toy Buzz Lightyear (Tim Allen) as her “deputy” and second in command.
Buzz is developing feelings for Jessie, which he may get her off her high horse long enough to consider. Because Jessie is fretting that Bonnie isn’t “playing” enough to be socialized. And her parents are all-too-quick to turn to a kids’ social media toy and the platform/gadget LilyPad (voiced by Greta Lee) to find her a peer group to fix her social anxiety disorder.
Former Sheriff Woody (Tom Hanks) is off with other cast-aways and his true-love Bo-Peep (Annie Potts), but still available for consulations.
And a cargo container of “Hi-Tech” Buzz Lightyear toys has washed overboard, activated itself, and taken on the goal of returning to “Star Command” — a brigade of Buzzes marching into the story for meeting in the third act.
Bonnie is getting bullied by her more social-media savvy contemporaries. Kids aren’t playing and whole classes of toys are being discarded, including the potty-training “screen” gadget Smarty Pants (Conan O’Brien), the mapping toy Atlas (Craig Robinson) and play-digital camera Snappy (Shelby Rabarra), who haven’t yet figured out their role as “part of the problem.”
How can they all come to an agreement on what it will take to win Bonnie some playmates without her surrendering to social media imprisonment in the process?
“I dunno, Jessie,” is Woody’s counsel. “Toys are for play. Tech is for…everything!”
A real horse, a pet pig, “automatic update/upgrades” and the like play into the plot, which any tech-savvy child will pick up on.
And the role of toys in childhood development is played around with, a conclusion is reached and then utterly wimped-out on, because God knows Disney online couldn’t withstand the criticism.
The childhood “play” sequences, imagining toy adventures, weddings, etc., are animated in sketchier form. And the night-and-day difference in character textures, sheens, etc., from the first “Toy Story” to this latest one is striking in a “filmed realism” sense.
But this is inferior product, an idea that’s been worn-out with characters not far removed from movie-turned-daily-kids-TV quality in terms of depth, voice-acting, story and the like.
Pixar has been rightly criticized for struggling with finding a new Big Idea. Watch the coming attractions before “Toy Story 5” and you’ll see how Disney, Universal and everybody else is facing the same story/script/character obstacles.
It’s great that they moved the “toy” story towards a plucky female character helping a little girl grow up with “Toy Story 5.” There are a couple of hard tugs at the heartstrings in the third act to give that something of a payoff. But it’s a crying shame they didn’t have more to say than that in the fifth film in the franchise that made their reputation, at least enough to justify sullying the brand in the process.
Rating: PG, toilet training humor
Cast: The voices of Joan Cusack, Tim Allen, Tom Hanks, Conan O’Brien, Greta Lee, Ernie Hudson, Scarlett Spears, Craig Robinson, Tony Hale and John Ratzenberger.
Credits: Scripted and directed by McKenna Harris and Andrew Stanton. A Pixar/Disney release.
Running time: 1:42
































