A story suffused with the idealism of youth, “23,000 Lives” is about young people acting on their best impulses to help during a crisis that governments — fretting over public opinion — were trying to keep at arm’s length.
It’s a sturdy, largely unembellished German (in English) film of young Germans teaming up to raise funds for a small ship that they could use to rescue refugees fleeing conflict, the rising climate crisis and general unrest in Africa and the Middle East for better lives in Europe.
If it lacks many melodramatic “Hollywood touches,” that’s in the interest of veracity. As it’s about a hot-button issue, xenophobes, racists and other conservatives have their lederhosen in a twist over these moral, idealistic young people taking matters into their own hands. No sense giving them grounds to complain. Which they were bound to do anyway.
The film sticks to the facts, with issues of human trafficking, government policies that exacerbate or alleviate the conditions that drive people to flee their homes to survive and that “better life” addressed, but largely left for another debate.
Because this story began with just one college-age kid and a simple statement of principle.
“Can we just let people drown?”
Louis Hoffman plays Lukas, a character based on Jacob Schoen, a German 19 year-old who finds direction and purpose when he hears of a tragic refugee raft sinking in the Mediterranean in 2015. His supportive college student girlfriend (Mala Emde) may not drop everything she’s doing to pitch in. But plenty of others do as the group, cause and project to be named “Jugend Rettet –– “Youth Saves” — organizes.
They need to buy a workboat/trawler/tug of some sort, vessels which turn out to be relatively cheap — at least in a Bezos/Zuckerberg yatching sense. They need to raise the hundred and fifty thousand Euros needed to buy it, more money to renovate it and refit it for their purposes and hire some professional seafarers to join their volunteer corps.
They need attention and they get it, as Lukas narrates about Europe’s generally compassionate attitude towards migrants at this moment. But attitudes will change as images of a sea of humanity flooding out of North Africa and the Middle East start to dominate international news.
“The world won’t change if no one does anything,” is how Lukas sees it.
We see them rebuffed by bankers, charities and governments, and take hard questions about their qualifications for doing any of this. And yet they persist.
As money comes in and the movement/team grows, we’re treated to the training these NGO (Non-government-organization) dreamers realize they need before putting to sea.
They round up a volunteer medical professional (Sabon Wang), a captain (Maria Dragus) and a others (Frederick Lau) with the expertise they need to organize rescues at sea.
“We’re really scared of messing up,” Lukas confesses. But as they start this dangerous work, contending with rubber rafts overfilled with panicked, traumatized refugees, most of whom speak no language their rescuers know, they don’t.
And right from the very first mission, they see the rewards in their “We can’t just wait for a just world” ethos. Trevor Magaya plays an English speaker in that first boat filled with Africans from Nigeria, Mozambique and Eritrea, a young man fleeing violence and marveling that people his age are coming to their rescue and taking care of a business.
The obstacles change as European and global public opinion shifts and the crew of the good ship Iuventa (“Youth”) contend not just with Libyan pirates or “militia,” but official European blowback that lands them in court.
Co-screenwriter Michelle Cinque did a documentary about this group’s efforts and Italian attempts to shut them down and scare off similar NGOs via the infamous Italian “justice” system. Cinque keeps the adaptation direct, not sensationalized or over-dramatized, with names changed and a few minor cinematic liberties.
Everything “factual” must be covered, even if only cursorily. But the film makes time to wrestle with the psychological scars of very young people leaving comfortable lives to face life and death situations without professional training or military indoctrination to guide them.
You have to be pretty far removed from your own humanity to not be touched by the desperate, often otherwise doomed refugees. And it’s easy to be inspired by the story of youth brought up to “do the right” and moral thing deciding to save lives and alleviate suffering, no matter what governments, haters and social media trolls think of you.
Rating: TV-MA, scenes of peril, threats of violence, profanity
Cast: Louis Hoffman, Mala Emde, Katharina Stark, Trevor Magaya, Maria Dragus, Kathy Etoa, Frederick Lau and Sabon Wang.
Credits: Directed by Markus Goller, scripted by Michelle Cinque and Oliver Ziegenbalg. A Netflix release.
Running time: 1:52






































