

“You, Me & Tuscany” is a featherweight romance with a pretty cast, lovely scenery, fabulous food and just a hint of charm under all the cliches.
It’s a Hallmark Lite rom-com built around live-action “Little Mermaid” star Halle Bailey, who struggles to sparkle in a drab script and a role that demands screen presence and vulnerability more than singing.
She is turned-out, made-up and perfectly coiffed in every shot “Under the Tuscan Sun.” And damned if everybody else in the cast doesn’t upstage her in scene after sunny scene.
Director Kat Coiro’s barely PG (It’s rated PG-13) romance concludes with outtakes of bit players cast as tourists scoring the movie’s only laughs. They riff lines about the fine hunk (“Bridgerton’s” Regé-Jean Page) our heroine has gotten soaked with in an irrigated vineyard.
“You can Diane Lane ME ‘Under the Tuscan Sun,’ if you get my drift.'” “You can ‘Eat, Pray, Love’ me anytime, Baby!”
Cute. And not exactly a vote of confidence in your star.
Bailey stars as Brianna, an aspiring chef who gets by house-sitting in New York, “borrowing” the clothes, jewelry, designer pets and lifestyle of her clients. Nia Vardalos of “My Big Fat Greek Wedding” plays the one client who blows up when she catches her in the act.
Brianna’s obligagory sassy-mouthed bestie Claire (Aziza Scott, funny) orders her to “Stop borrowing other people’s lives and start living your own.” She underscores every bit of life advice with “Bitch!” Because of course she does.
Broke, still mourning her late mother — a chef — but into high living, Brianna treats herself to a drink and burger at the bar in the hotel where Claire is concierge. That’s where the handsome globetroter Matteo (Lorenzo de Moor) meets her, charms her and invites her up to his room.
Him dozing off pre coitus isn’t a complete waste, she figures, as she reasons that he “Pretty much invited me to stay” in his empty villa in his hometown of San Conessa. A flat-broke fish out of water, naturally she tries on a wedding ring she finds in a dresser once she gets there. That’s how Matteo’s family, estranged from him since he took off to make his fortune in real estate, decides she’s his fiance and that he’s coming home for a wedding.
“Anna” lies just enough to encourage this.
Mama (Isabella Ferrari), cranky granny (Stefania Cassini) and ribald cousin Francesca (Stella Pecollo) spring into wedding planning, gushing over and bowling over the bride-to-be, who speaks Italian and knows Italian cuisine, which could come in handy at the family ristorante. You think?
And then the “other” son in the famiglia, vineyard owner Michael (Page) has his “meet cute” with the American, and things get complicated in the most trite and predictable ways.
The film’s setting is the Italy and the Tuscany of Italian cliche — vineyards and postcard-perfect villages and fine food and laughing, friendly locals, a place where a romantic gal .awakens each day to the groundskeeper’s perfectly passable rendition of “Libiamo ne’ lieti calici.”
Its script is packed with lazy devices, worn-out plot contrivances and dialogue crutches. “In EEEEtaly, we have a saying…Those who know food, know life.” and “In vino veritas.” And so on.
Bailey struggles to give “Anna” in Italy a personality to go along with the lovely wardrobe, Rapunzel-length braids, lush settings and spritely co-stars. But when even her taxi-driver/confidante Lorenzo (Marco Calvani) has more personality, you start to grasp the film’s central failing.
Our star is content to be the pretty ornament whom all the funny and often more fleshed-out characters spin around. And she doesn’t have the screen presence for that.
Films fail for a lot of reasons, almost all of them behind the camera — weak script, lackluster direction, poor pacing, etc. But every now and then, miscasting or an out-of-her-depth lead performance also takes some of the blame. I hate to say this, given the nonsense she went through when she was cast as “The Little Mermaid,” but Bailey isn’t up to carrying this off.
When she finally breaks into song near this bland tale’s bland finale, you can sense her relief and ponder the muttering her director must have done behind the camera.
“Why didn’t we have her sing from the start?”
Rating: PG-13, profanity
Cast: Halle Bailey, Regé-Jean Page, Lorenzo de Moor, Marco Calvani, Isabella Ferrari, Stella Pecollo, and Aziza Scott
Credits: Directed by Kat Coiro, scripted by Ryan Engle and Kristen Engle. A Universal release.
Running time: 1:4




























