


Timing, especially in comedy, is everything. But Sony Pictures Classics had no way of knowing that its Oscar-campaigned Jewish Holocaust dramedy “Eleanor the Great” would come out in the middle of worldwide outrage at an ongoing Israeli genocide in Gaza.
Woody Allen darling Scarlett Johansson’s directing debut and perhaps June Squibb’s best shot at major awards arrived at a moment when the public at large wasn’t in the mood for yet another “Never again” Holocaust story, this one about a woman who claimed to be a “survivor,” and wasn’t.
It’s well-acted all-around. And some would be more forgiving of its parade of third-act stumbles, blunders and “It’ll all work out in the end” contrivances. Because Holocaust stories in general and tales of grief and remembrances have historically earned the benefit of the doubt.
But any sober consideration of this movie about a survivor’s best friend keeping her memories if not her memory alive via lies has to grapple with the blunt truth that it doesn’t really work.
We meet Eleanor (Squibb) and Polish immigrant Bessie (Rita Zohar) as they wind down the last good years of their lives in Florida. They’ve been friends since the ’50s and in New York — widowed and in Florida for over a decade.
As roommates, the amusingly abrasive Eleanor knows Bessie’s story and the reasons for her nightmares. Their past together was happy, and there’s a shared Bronx-hardened sarcastic intolerance for any Florida store clerk who doesn’t keep the kosher pickles supply stocked in their market.
Where’s your sense of humor, ladies?
“Hitler took my smile,” Bessie spits. Eleanor seconds this, only to be reproved by a mutual friend who knows she was no closer to the Holocaust than Coney Island.
Bessie dies. Eleanor moves back to New York, in with her divorced daughter (Jessica Hecht of “Friends”) and the “one good Jew in the family,” her doting college student grandson Max (Will Price).
Stressed working daughter Lisa is anxious to find Mom a little assisted living. But in the meantime, she tries to keep Eleanor connected with their community by signing her up for a music ensemble at their Jewish Community Center. And that’s where it all goes wrong.
Eleanor ducks into the wrong group meeting, and when Holocaust survivors talk about their grief and their experiences in their support group, Eleanor chimes in by repeating Bessie’s experiences as her own. She’s “fitting in” by stealing a Holocaust survivor’s trauma.
The film brushes by any guilt she feels about this and stumbles somewhat as Eleanor’s lies take on more consequence when an NYU journalism student (Erin Kellyman, terrific) picks up the story and that student’s TV anchor dad (Chiwetel Ejiofor) raises the stakes even further when he sees “an angle.”
I kept waiting for Eleanor’s lack of a concentration camp tattoo or, you know, basic research by the “reporters” or old acquaintances (she’s 94, there aren’t any of those) trip her up.
Instead, Tory Kamen’s script takes us into Eleanor’s pursuit of a late life bat mitzvah, with a rabbi (Stephen Singer) assigning her the ethically problematic story of Jacob and Esau as her Torah passage to memorize and recite in Hebrew.
That’s a tad on the nose, as this Biblical tale of a brother’s deceit allowing him to steal a sibling’s birthright is an origin story that excuses, rationalizes and brushes over a lot — rather like “Eleanor the Great.”
Squibb is fine and makes the most of another late career showcase, no matter where the ungainly plot takes her. Hecht is called on to play the struggling daughter who acts most undaughterly — with cause — when the you-know-what hits the fan.
Kellyman, playing a student eager to please a journalist dad but mourning her own Jewish’s mother’s death, is subtle and moving. Ejiofor should have called a journalist friend or two about what could have been done with the nonsense Kamen scripted for the journalistic finale.
But Zohar is the heart of the piece, and anybody who’s ever met a Holocaust survivor will recognize the haunted life behind her performance. Others are good, she is wonderful.
I’ve interviewed Holocaust survivors over the years, and the worst thing about such live (public) radio chats is fighting tears because you know how unprofessional that might appear. At least in print, you have the distance provided by the keyboard.
But if the Holocaust was, as some have observed, a moment that was “The End of History,” then we may be hitting the end of the road of the Holocaust drama and documentary epoch. The scores of documentaries about survivors that I’ve reviewed have lately played as repetitivie, stale and downright hypocritical.
A South African survivor’s family tries to trauma-coat the prosperous life she lived after marrying a South African and Ms. “Never Again” profited from decades and decades of apartheid, which she did not protest. And so on.
I think of her every time I see fresh accounts of what’s happening in Gaza and now Lebanon.
“Stolen valor” stories crossed my path in my Florida journalism years, where a documentary about The Tuskegee Airmen, filming gatherings of those survivors, revealed that their ranks were contaminated by poseurs who pretended to have served with those heroic World War II pilots and did not.
People exaggerate their connection to epic moments in history all the time, not just those running for office. There’s little that’s cute or “revealing the depth of grief” in a movie that tries its damnedest to brush by big lies, especially one that uses the story of Jacob and Esau to excuse it.
Whatever reactions Johansson, Squibb and Sony Pictures Classics were going for, pissed-off must have hit them by surprise. And it shouldn’t have.
Rating: PG-13, for “thematic material” (Holocaust descriptions), sexual references, profanity
Cast: June Squibb, Erin Kellyman, Jessica Hecht, Rita Zohar, Will Price and Chiwetel Ejiofor
Credits: Directed by Scarlett Johansson, scripted by Tory Kamen. A Sony Pictures Classics release on Netflix.
Running time: 1:38


































