“Carolina Caroline” is a rigidly formulaic romantic thriller about a couple who meet as grifter-and-trainee and abruptly graduate from picking pockets and quick change scams to bank robberies.
It’s dogmatic to the point where any potential surprise is smothered out of it, starting with an opening scene narrative framing device that gives away who’s still on the lam after it all hits the fan.
Screenwriter Tom Dean follows the outline of a hundred “Bonnie and Clydes” and “Dirty Mary and Crazy Larry’s” before him. Director Adam Carter Rehmeir (“Snack Shack”) can’t inject much novelty or suspense into that, and manages only one nervy getaway amid the mandatory waypoints of such sagas.
But it stars “Ready or Not” queen Samara Weaving and “Strange Darling” demon Kyle Gallner, so we hold out hope for sparks that rarely fly and fireworks that never go off.
Caroline is a convenience store worker who picks up on the handsome stranger’s bit of short-change trickery with her boss, and that leads to a honky tonk pick-up and a midnight swim down’tha quarry in this corner of BFE, Texas.
Oliver (Gallner) asks her the Big Question straight off.
“What are you still doing here?”
Potential beauty queen or not, Caroline’s dreams are as limited as her possibilities. She’d love to “travel,” maybe go as far as South Carolina.
When he asks her to “go out on like 500 dates with me,” she counters by requesting that her philospher grifter to “teach me how to con.”
Thus begins a criminal odyssey across the early 1990s/early-2000s South — stealing from high end department stores and businessmen on trains, living big in nice hotels, eating in good restaurants and filling out wardrobes well beyond the means of the petty thievery they’re carrying out.
But if they want to up their game, they’ll have to swipe getaway cars because even 25 years ago, Oliver’s 1970 Chevelle was too conspicuous for any thief — petty or GTA or armed robber — to manage a getaway.
As the story is saddled with a “three months earlier” timeframe in the opening, we’re meant to buy into Caroline’s impulse-driving escalations in crime. Weaving’s performance, washed out and reduced to Daisy Dukes and boots and bare midriff-wear, doesn’t make that sale.
Gallner’s playing a 30something grifter who reads people and memorizes IDs and has figured out to “exploit flaws in a given system” by recognizing and preying on human flaws.
“Everybody lies. Especially to themselves.”
He can guess that lie and use it to his advantage. Caroline? She’s just Margot Robbie-distracting by birth.
Weaving loses the Oz accent but doesn’t replace it with a Texas one.
Little insights like sharing the “fear that we’ll end up like the parent that left” each of them in childhood aren’t deep.
Caroline’s devotion to her daddy (Jon Gries) is taken as a given, even as he lets her take off with a goateed stranger — from California, no less. And the family joke about “Ecuador” is so dull and uninteresting that it must be foreshadowing.
Kyra Sedgwick breathes some fire into this road picture with careless, sloppy bank robberies as a defiant barfly.
But this narrative is so worn and this variation on it so watered-down from the decades of genre pictures that preceded it that the filmmakers and actors have to convince us that “60 second” robberies are casually planned, practiced and carried out.
“It’s easy, right?” No, it isn’t.
And setting your movie in the pre-CCTV surveillance state/phone booth/no cell phones seen/stealable-with-a-screwdriver cars era doesn’t make it more plausible. Not in the least.
Rating: unrated, violence, sex, profanity
Cast: Samara Weaving, Kyle Gallner, Jon Gries and Kyra Sedgwick.
Credits: Directed by Adam Rehmeir, scripted by Tom Dean. A Magnolia Films release.
Runnin time: 1:45







































