A good gimmick goes a long way in a romantic comedy, because basically, there’s been nothing truly “new” in the genre since “Much Ado About Nothing.”
Writer, director, actor and composer Rudy Mancuso borrowed the musical commentator on the action of “Musica” from “There’s Something About Mary.” We hear a busker singing about how our hero needs to “change” as young Rudy passes him on the way into the subway each day.
Instead of Jonathan Richman crooning “Mary Mary, there’s something about Mary,” we hear “It” and “Flash” director (and perhaps future “Batman” director) Andy Muschietti crooning and picking out the musical advice on a guitar.
Cute.
Mancuso “borrows” the lovelorn, comical “guy who just wants to work with puppets” subtext from Jason Segal’s “Forgetting Sarah Marshall” turn.
But what sells this autobiographical musical romance is the adorable touch of having our hero hear the music in everyday life, a distracted young man who imagines “Stomp” production numbers breaking out with the people rattling pots, pans, glasses and cutlery at a diner, in the activities at a street market, in a seafood shop and even in a hospital emergency room.
Mancuso’s picture pops right off the screen, right at the start, with such a number breaking out on a commuter train. He is the deadpan center of all this joyous mayhem, sullenly sitting and recognizing that maybe he does have a problem with focus and concentration.
The rhythm’s got him. Bad.
Every time this gimmick is repeated, it works. And that’s a lucky thing, but there really is nothing new about rom-com plots, situations and dialogue. Mancuso is a Brazilian American Greater Newark (Ironbound) college kid torn between the preppy college girlfriend (Francesca Reale) who is “making plans” for their lives together in “The City” (NYC) and the down to earth, laid-back fish market cutie played by Camila Mendes of “Palm Springs” and TV’s “Riverdale.”
Seriously, if you don’t know how all this will resolve itself, you need to get out more. Or, you know, stream more.
Mancuso, of “Rim of the World,” must’ve handed this script to his “Flash” director Muschietti to land that lovely cameo. Playing a version of himself — the story is pitched as “a true story, unfortunately” — he manages to be a little more than a forelock-flopping haircut and self-conscious lead. But not much more.
But he’s good looking and engaging enough in a part that can’t help but charm. Rudy’s a mama’s boy who talks to his hairdresser mother (Maria Mancuso, awwww) in Portuguese and can barely pay attention in marketing class, drawing page-animations in his notebook, ears perking up at every unusual sound.
The film’s chapters are labeled “Rhythm, “Dissonance,” “Dynamics,” “Melody” and the like.
Rudy must get dumped by his upper-classic girlfriend of four years, Haley, only to face her having “security” related second thoughts. He must be nagged by his mama that “Gringa women are no good,” and have her try to set him up with a Brazilian.
“You’re my mom, not my pimp!”
He confides in Diego, his subway puppet, and in Anwar, the go-with-the-flow food truck operator who serves everybody — Greeks, Muslims and Orthodox Jews — pandering to each customer base as he rolls up, changing menus and hats (yarmulke included) because to Anwar, “It ain’t where you’re from, it’s where you’re AT.”
He is played by by that Brigadier General of Banter, J. B. Smoove.
Mancuso cooks up one cute scene after another, with Rudy’s sense of rhythm and knowledge of “The International Language of Music” underscoring the gimmicks he trots out, and the jokes. Meeting college girlfriend Haley in a Brazilian restaurant, he and the house keyboards player swap messages about how badly he’s handling his two-girlfriend situation in rhythmic code.
Mendes and Reale are good, but Mancuso lets his mom steal the darned movie with one saucy, semi-offensive Portugeuse insult after another.
No, there isn’t much to “the story,” and certainly little in the basic situation that we haven’t seen in movies about Italians, Greeks, Spanish, gay or young or old characters.
But the musical novelty numbers absolutely make the featherweight “Musica” come off.
Rating: PG-13, one scene of gun violence, profanity
Cast: Rudy Mancuso, Camila Mendes, Francesca Reale, Maria Mancuso and Jay B Smoove
Credits: Directed by Rudy Mancuso, scripted by Rudy Mancuso and Dan Lagan. An MGM/Amazon release.
Running time: 1:32