One of the most formative books from my movie fanatic youth was Theodore Gershuny’s “Soon to be a Major Motion Picture: The Anatomy of an All-Star, Big-Budget Multi-Million Dollar Disaster.”
Gershuny’s on-set/in-the-studio observation of the making of Otto Preminger’s greatest debacle, “Rosebud,” remains — I dare say — a definitive eye-opener and an insightful foray into how movies are made and how they can go as wrong as they often do.
Whole epochs in technology, the shape and demographics of the audience and the very business model of making movies have evolved and devolved since 1975. But Gershuny’s all-access account of what it’s like when money, locations, stars and crew are on board the Major Motion Picture train when a production leaves the station with a very bad but “We’ll fix it” script in hand remains a cautionary tale as informative as any investigation of the disaster that was “Heaven’s Gate” or the triumph against the odds that “Apocalypse Now” turned out to be.
Egos, agendas, one hard-drinking “action” star (Robert Mitchum) quits and another (Peter O’Toole) is cast in his place, contempuous sexism and Zionism and retrograde attitudes that play as stunningly tone-deaf today, it’s a “miracle” “Rosebud” ever got the green light. The film was already hard to get one’s hands on in 1980, when the book came out. And despite being a Peter O’Toole fanatic and a (director) Otto Preminger appreciator, I could never make myself watch it when “Rosebud” aired on cable or streamed. Until now.




The film, based on a novel by Joan Hemingway (Ernest’s granddaughter) and Paul Bonnecarrère, came out during a peak era of Middle East unrest, when Palestinians used terrorist acts such as hijackings and the Munich Olympics mass-kidnapping and massacre to call attention to their plight.
They were being displaced and “erased” from their homeland while the whole world looked away.
American foreign policy was very much bent to Israel’s will — even then (something addressed in the film). But there were countries and public figures (Vanessa Redgrave, for one) who had Palestinian sympathies, even then, something John Le Carre’s 1983 thriller “The Little Drummer Girl” touched on.
That’s the climate that Preminger — a directing legend who had given us “Laura,” “Anatomy of a Murder,” “Advise & Consent” and perhaps most tellingly, “Exodus” — made one of his most topical movies, “Rosebud” in.
The global elite would be the target of the film’s smiling, swaggering but generally colorless terrorists. We see them plan and prep their plot when they gather in Corsica. Meanwhile, the daughters of Greek, British, American and other super-rich are gathering on a yacht named after the sled in “Citizen Kane.”
Sabine (Brigitte Ariel) may have taken a leftist French school teacher lover who ruffles her superrich father’s (Claude Dauphin) feathers. But she’s blithely unaware that her money only insulates her from daddy’s fury. There are others watching, waiting and planning their undoing.
The very young Isabelle Huppert and Kim Cattrall are among Sabine’s Rolls Royce chauffeured quintet (Lalla Ward and Debra Berger also co-star), the daughters of an English lord (Peter Lawford) and American senator (ex-New York majoy John Lindsay) among them.
When they’re set-up and nabbed and the yacht’s crew are killed, everybody involved knows the worst has happened. That’s why the (secretly Jewish) shipping tycoon Fargeau (Dauphin) grasps for private help.
Larry Martin (O’Toole) is a Paris-based correspondent for Newsweek, a Brit who’s also a covert hired “fixer” for the CIA. He’s at home in this world, used to tracking down terrorists, dealing with Mossad and mitigating one bad outcome for another. He’s cocky, charming and competent, an expert in getting the answers and results he wants.
Meanwhile, the terrorists make films for The Media, and everybody around the world cooperates to “save these girls,” save for the U.S., which is most easily coerced into doing Israel’s bidding.
As the chase begins and the hunt for the terrorist mastermind (Richard Attenborough, in one of the great casting miscalculations ever) takes our louche anti-hero all over Europe and the Med.
What could go wrong with either side’s best-laid plans, or the movie? Gosh, where does one begin?
Continue reading




























