



“Madden” is a great big black mark on the resume of writer-director David O. Russell, a miscast $75 million debacle that plays like an overlong, underwhelming trailer to a mini-series about a football player turned coach turned master-class-in-football analyst turned video game brand.
Whatever drew the director of “Silver Linings Playbook” and “The Fighter” to this material is a mystery, as it wasn’t the history — which he mangles — and it wasn’t the game, which he stumbles and struggles to comprehend. This is an even less joyous “Joy,” a more hate-able “I Heart Huckabees” and an “Amsterdam” that should finally convince Christian Bale that being the best thing in a bad movie for his “Fighter” director just isn’t worth it.
Russell takes the ultimate “Regular Guy,” a working class offensive lineman turned passionate coach and a man of infinite eccentricities — from his roadside diet and aversion to flying to the unrestrained enthusiasm he brought to a game he understood like few before or since, enthusiasm he unleashed on viewers on Any Given Sunday — and renders him into a half-hearted Nicolas Cage cartoon.
Will Ferrell was up for this role. That casting might have been just as wrong, but it sure as hell would have been funnier. Like Madden.
Russell tries to tell too much story. He takes John Madden from his struggles to finally “win the big one” with that most cinematic of NFL teams — the ’70s Raiders and their quarterback nicknamed “Snake,” a stand-out defender called an “Assassin” and a chainsmoking receiver who never missed a ball thanks to being covered in “stick’em” — on through his early health-and-marriage-driven “retirement,” to his new purpose in life, trying to explain the game to laymen viewers of The NFL on CBS while not restraining his enthusiasm, and into his influence over the wildly popular NFL video game that bears his name.
The saga circles around the deep friendship between the EveryMan coach and his rags-to-riches compadre, working class Oakland Raiders hustler Al Davis. Mr. “Just win, baby” is given a riverboat gambler/made man swagger by Oscar winner Christian Bale, who doesn’t so much steal the movie as make it endurable for chunks of time.
Kathryn Hahn brings sass and brass to Virginia Madden, the long-suffering wife of a man married to his work because his boss was married to his. And Sienna Miller is well-cast as Mrs. Davis, just the sort of saucy blonde you’d expect on a hair-slicked mobster-look-alike’s arm.
But Russell’s so out of his depth that he recreates Madden enthusing up and down the sidelines, bellowing variations of “This is IT” and other inanities as seen on the NFL Films of the era. We hear and see Madden thinking up plays and strategies, but Russell is inept at showing that, or the outcome of Madden’s inspirations.
Cage doesn’t look like Madden or sound like him. But he picks up some mannerisms and gives us a hint of the voice, and honestly, he’s OK at playing a guy with big appetites and a big heart.
Forced to retire to save his health — bleeding ulcers, etc. — and save his marriage, Madden’s at a loss, confiding in his dog. But CBS calls, and while Davis may (or may not have) played a role in the pitch, that’s who Coach complains to when trying to turn it down.
“Those (TV) guys are nothing but HAIRCUTS, Al!”
Yes, young pup “haircut” Bob Costas was Madden’s audition partner and um, TV announcing “coach.” No, one can’t imagine egoist Howard Cosell obnoxiously comforting ex-kicker-turned-“haircut” Pat Summerall (Joel McHale) over having “this AMATEUR” replace Summerall’s celebrated broadcast booth sidekick Tom Brookshier. One also can’t imagine the courtly Summerall being this rude to his new “partner,” either. But as McHale gives no hint of the veteran broadcaster’s booming voice, presence or grace, that was always a “thrown for a loss” attempt.
Russell invents a fanatical Raiders fan neighbor (Shane Gillis) intended as a joker/witness to Madden’s highs and lows, which doesn’t work.
The words that keep popping to mind enduring “Madden” are “bloated” and “messy,” as the entire enterprise is both an overreach and over-hype. This Madden craved the immortality of the NFL Hall of Fame, where dead icons never die. And he got it. So?
He’s the sort of fellow you’d bump into on his road trips by personal bus at a diner in BFE Iowa, Kansas or wherever, and be on his Christmas card list for the rest of his life. The script and Cage never come close to erasing the “So what?” of that, either.
A better end point would have been the moment the EA game was pitched, as it’s the thing recent generations most associate with the name. Let EA top dog Hawkins (John Mulaney, meh) try and fail and try again to make that sale, and leave us with “And the rest is history.”
And a better first act would have not just included Madden’s humanity and guilt-ridden grief at what one of his players did to opponent Darryl Stingley. It would have shown us Oakland as a rough-and-tumble town for pro sports, with fans who reflected the “outlaw” tribe on the field, and cast more colorful actors as Kenny “The Snake” Stabler, Fred Biletnikoff, Jack Tatum, Sistrunk, Casper, Matusak and Hendricks.
The “Madden” we get never lets us forget it was once intended for the big screen as it shrinks and shrinks and shrinks some more on its way down to the “made for TV” movie it became.
Rating: R, football violence, smoking and lots of profanity
Cast: Nicolas Cage, Kathryn Hahn, Sienna Miller, John Mulaney, Joel Murray and Christian Bale
Credits: Directed by David O. Russell, scripted by David O. Russell and Cambron Clark. An MGM release on Amazon Prime.
Running time: 1:50

