There’s validity in taking “A Christmas Carol” back to its chilling holiday ghost story origins. And letting one of the edgiest horror directors of today have a crack at “God bless us, every one” isn’t exactly crazy, per se.
Make a version of this well-worn tale that speaks to modern times and modern audiences, cynicism and greed stared down by kindness and charity — or scared to death — might work.
But I think it’s safe to say that Ti West (“X,””Pearl”) isn’t the director anyone — other than the bros apparently running Paramount — figures would pull something like that, or even a film version far less ambitious, off.
“Ebenezer” is a relentlessly downbeat walk down the snowy, familiar Dickensian London paht, pretty much humorless and utterly joyless, from its cynical opening “stave” to the drawn out fumble that passes for an ending this time round.
If Johnny Depp was hoping to launch a “comeback” from his scandal-shortened career by twinkling through “Ebenezer” Scrooge, good luck. And pity the parents taking their kids to see the latest version of that most sentimental of holiday stories, only to be treated to cadaverous specters, Victorian Walking Dead and the white-eyed wraith that West turns the lovely Andrea Riseborough into as the Ghost of Christmas Past.
Sure, let us see Jacob Marley before death. He’s played by Sir Ian McKellen, after all. And that’s usually a single scene role on the stage or the screen. But nobody needs to see the true fate of Mr. Fezziwig, young Ebenezer’s (Arthur Conti) jovial and work-life balance preaching first employer.





We all know the plot, right? So it kind of matters with how diminished Tiny Tim’s place in all this might be, especially when we’re treated to more pointless diversions from the text with Scrooge’s first love, Belle (Ellie Bamber and Sara Galvin).
“Beggars” take an almost Trumpian beatdown in West and screenwriter Nathanael Halpern’s eyes. One’s faking a lost eye, another’s a killer, and so on.
The Ghost of Christmas Present, usually the jolliest of characters, is a piggish bully (Trammel Tillman) with awful table manners and no subtlety.
Depp, grizzled, jowly and bearing a fake nose, is tolerable in a role Alastair Sim owned in the distant past, and which George C. Scott brought to most vivid life in a 1984 TV movie you can still find airing or streaming all through the holidays.
Rupert Grint is the most dour Bob Cratchit ever, plainly out of his Ron Weasley depth. Sam Claflin makes an earnest “nephew Fred,” the fellow who tries and tries to get Uncle Ebenezer to go easy on the humbugs. But even that performance lacks the relentlessly upbeat fun that we normally see in the character. Daisy Ridley makes a decent enough impression as Fred’s Scrooge-disliking wife.
McKellen has the best chance to shine, and with two scenes, he gives it his all. It’s not enough.
The viewer has to grapple with choices that don’t seem to have been given much thought by the filmmakers, all of them pointing towards the conclusion that this may be the most pointless “Christmas Carol” of them all.
And as we’ll seen a computer animated Jim Carrey take and a boorish, coarse and “modern” TV exec version with Bill Murray, that’s saying something.
I appreciated the attention to grey, Industrial Revolution poverty detail.
Rating: PG-13, violence, horrific images
Cast: Johnny Depp, Rupert Grint, Andrea Riseborough, Trammel Tillman, Daisy Ridley, Sam Claflin and Sir Ian McKellen.
Credits: Directed by Ti West, scripted by Nathanael Halpern, based on “A Christmas Carol” by Charles Dickens. A Paramount release.
Running time: 1:50

