Chiwetel Ejiofor‘s “Rob Peace” surfs the ebb and flow of one life in making an age-old point about race and life in America. Simply put, it underscores the message of generations of TV ads for The United Negro College Fund — “A Mind is a Terrible Thing to Waste.”
Here, we’re told a true story (base don a Jeff Hobbs biography) of a brilliant, focused mind aimed at a life of “curing cancer,” but redirected, time and again, by the demands of growing up Black in New Jersey.
We meet Robert DeShaun Peace (Jelani Dacres) as a seven year old math whiz, dazzling his Dad (Ejiofor) with his ability to work out baseball batting averages, his mother’s (Mary J. Blige) family budget and the like, a child who lives for Dad’s weekly visits.
His first memory, he narrates, is of “the day my father’s house burned down,” “the last day I remember being a child.”
He recalls an informal ball game listening party on the stoop of his mother’s apartment complex, the older neighbor who figures he’s “the cavalry that’s going to turn this neighborhood around.” His father’s old Lincoln broke down that day and limited where this weekly visit would wind up. But the kid noted his personable father Skeet’s circle of friends and connections, and the lesson Dad imparts from that.
“You look out for people” and someday they’ll “look out for you.”
There was a revolver, shots fired and a fire. And next thing he knows, Dad is in jail for a double homocide.
Hired-cook Mom vows to do whatever it takes to get Shaun into private school, to have Shaun use “your first name” so that he’s not associated with his father’s incarceration by anyone he meets. The kid’s fascination with the race-and-class-blind cut-and-dried truths of science will take a lifelong back seat to his father’s pleas — to a very young, impressionable and smart child — that he “get me out.”
Shaun will be Rob, and he will take on his father’s case, his crumbling neighborhood and the limited expectations of his circumstances because he’s the family hero on horseback and “the cavalry’s coming.”
Getting into all-Black parochial school St. Benedict’s is step one, where the kind priest in charge (Michael Kelly) makes sure the boys there learn the school motto — “Whatever hurts my brother hurts me.” Getting the grades and class achievements it takes to get into a great college is step two.
Dad’s case? There’s evidence that the State ignored, allegations of a murder weapon switch, enough for an appeal. “I can file that for you,” teenaged Rob (Jay Will) reassures his increasingly desperate father.
Yale? Whatever race or class challenges face him there, Rob’s obvious talent trumps them. He assures his classmates of color (Camilla Cabello, Caleb Eberhart, etc.) that “race” isn’t an issue there.
“I’m not about to keep my guard up if nobody’s swinging” at him, he chuckles.
Ejiofor’s film goes to great pains to avoid the “white savior” trap, emphasizing the American meritocracy that theoretically should celebrate brilliant minds like Rob. The priest, the college professor (Mare Winningham) who recognize his talent do what we’d expect people trained to nuture talent do.
But as Rob tells his story in voice-over narration taken from his grad school application essay, we see the many ways he’s been on his own and how he has to use that brilliance to add potency to marijuana he and a couple of classmates cook-up for the cash needed for school and to finance his father’s appeal.
Rob will parlay that into a long-gestating house-flipping scheme back home in East Orange, because that’s another thing that brilliant mind sees before everyone else. And as he does all this, he will bring change to his world and forever alter the lives of the friends who throw in with him.
He may guard his family “secret,” reluctant even to reveal his father’s imprisonment even to his Yale girlfriend (Cabello). He may be shaken by the degree to which his father expects his genius son to save him. But Rob somehow rolls with it, shrugging off the culture clashes inherent in an institution like Yale, bringing people together on schemes that don’t just result in ready cash, but put everybody on the same side pushing towards a common goal.
Ejiofor’s film struggles to contain all that ambition, a working poor kid who starts to improve his world while still an undergrad, a college science student navigating a legal system fraught with lazy prosecutors, corrupt cops and judges drunk on their own power, even the ones inclined to see the “rigged” system’s injustices.
Will, of TV’s “Tulsa King” and “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel,” holds his own with his Oscar-nominated writer-director co-star Ejiofor, and impresses in every scene. It’s no easy feat, conveying confidence and intelligence that sees beyond the simple inexperience of youth and limitations of class.
Rob can be cocky about his prospects in ways that persuade others to join his ventures. But they also see his sense of decency, the fairness and “We’re all in this together” ethos that supercedes any competitive edge he might be hiding.
“Rob Peace” meanders as it tries to get all this in. Narration as framework aside, it can be hard to keep track of this or that “prize” that Rob turns his eye towards.
But Will, Ejiofor and Blige, as a mother who never wavers from what she sees as her primary duty, make this odyssey feel personal and the pitfalls we see coming and ever-mounting life tests seem surmountable if only this brilliant mind isn’t wasted by an America reluctant to embrace “Whatever hurts my brother hurts me.”
Rating: R, violence, drug abuse, profanity
Cast: Jay Will, Chiwetel Ejiofor, Mary J. Blige, Camilla Cabello, Juan Castono, Curt Morlaye, Caleb Eberhardt, Michael Kelly and Mare Winningham.
Credits: Scripted and directed by Chiwetel Ejiofor, based on a book by Jeff Hobbs. A Republic Pictures/Paramount release.
Running time: 1:57