Classic Film Review: “Detour” (1945), still as Noir as Film Noir Gets

“That’s life,” the anti-hero of “Detour” growls in voice-over. “Whichever way you turn, fate sticks out a foot to trip you.”

Hardboiled, archetype-upending and gorgeous in its bare-bones minimalism, “Detour” is quintessential film noir.

“The Maltese Falcon” preceded it and “The Big Sleep” followed it — big studio productions with Bogie and Lorre and Bacall and John Huston conjuring up a genre that the French would later label “film noir.” But cheap, briskly-shot and briskly-cut “Detour” is the great primer on the genre.

Nobody in it got famous. And the director never shook his “B-movie” bonafides.

Even in this now-acknowledged classic, we see the sloppiness of low budget haste — images flipped to show cars going east instead of west, with the driver and steering wheel on the wrong side — and the crutch of “narration” was never more superfluous in a film that was voice-over narrated to death.

But this lean, blunt and talky thriller grew in stature over the decades. The lore attached to it was added to again and again, and was often wrong — “shot in a week” — and troubling when it wasn’t. Read boxer-turned-star Tom Neal‘s later life biography if you want to know what I mean.

In 1992 “Detour” was added to the National Film Registry by the Library of Congress, denoting it as essential cinema and one of the finest films to come out of that cynical, world-weary/underworld-friendly genre that took Hollywood by storm after World War II made the movies and America grow up.

I hadn’t seen it since its 2018 restoration. That’s as good an excuse as any to dive back into an all-time favorite.

Neal plays a rumpled, grimy hitchhiker when we meet him in a Reno diner late one night. Al Roberts has the haunted look of a man who’s seen things, done things and heard things.

He’s been west. He’s headed east. And that’s about all you’ll get out of him.

So whatever you do, don’t play the wrong song (“I Can’t Believe You’re in Love With Me”) on the jukebox.

“Wait a MINUTE, pal! That’s my nickel, see?”

As the lights in diner dim around his stubbly face, Al’s interior monologue — the flashback of the life that brought him here — begins.

There was New York, a nightspot called the Break’O Dawn. And there was a dame — Sue (Claudia Drake) — the singer where Al played the piano.

“Let’s split this town,” says she.

“Next week we’re gonna make with the ring and the license,” he counters.

But “split” she did. And when the longing grows too much, Al takes a $10 tip, a “piece of paper covered with germs — it couldn’t buy me nothin’ I want” and sets out by thumb across country as “I’m Always Chasing Rainbows” wafts into the score for the first of many times.

“If only I’d known what I was getting into that day in Arizona,” when he thumbed that last ride to the left coast in the Lincoln V-12 convertible of a big-talking bookie (Edmund MacDonald).

A death will follow, one “nobody’ll believe” was an accident. And a brassy, bullying hitchhiker — Vera (Ann Savage) — runs into our guy in that high-end Lincoln and proceeds to guess what’s happened and work the angles, threatening her way into blackmail.

We don’t have time to wonder why this piano player would give the femma fatale his real name. We’re dumped into this jam with him, wondering if she’ll rat him out, help him out or somehow manage to do both.

Savage gives one of those performances so far ahead of the gender curve that it was almost certain to make her a screen immortal. Her Vera is a tough broad and a vile schemer, and not as smart as she figures she is.

“If you act wise, well, mister, you’ll pop into jail so fast it’ll give you the bends!”

Neal never lets us forget that whatever this guy’s temper, he’s still just a piano player and nobody’s idea of a tough guy.

Director Ulmer and his just-as-efficient director of photography Benjamin H. Kline (he’d go on to decades of TV drama cinematography) manage several artistic flourishes in the framing and screen compositions.

But Ulmer’s focus on telling a story quickly had him turn the movie into a radio drama with pretty, shadowy/foggy black and white pictures, thanks to a remedial over-reliance on voice-over narration

“As I drove off, it was still raining and the drops streaked down the windshield like tears,” Al narrates what we already see. “Then she turned around to face me.” Let’s restate the obvious, over and over.

But if we accept it from flinty private eyes in film noir, we’re obligated to let this grating flaw slide. “Detour” is that good.

There’s no Bogart, and no Howard Hawks or John Huston, Fritz Lang or Ida Lupino behind the camera. But “Detour” remains the exemplar of the genre, the formulas and dominant themes — an “innocent” man jaded by the illusion of justice, trapped in a corrupt, unforgiving “system.”

You simply cannot call yourself a film buff until you’ve seen this, restored to its crackling, waste-no-screen-time brilliance.

Rating: TV-PG, violence

Cast: Tom Neal, Ann Savage, Claudia Drake and Edmund MacDonald.

Credits: Directed by Edgar G. Ulmer, scripted by Martin Goldsmith. A Producers Releasing Corporation film on Tubi, Youtube, Netflix, other streamers.

Running time: 1:08

Unknown's avatar

About Roger Moore

Movie Critic, formerly with McClatchy-Tribune News Service, Orlando Sentinel, published in Spin Magazine, The World and now published here, Orlando Magazine, Autoweek Magazine
This entry was posted in Reviews, previews, profiles and movie news and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.